Candidate Experience in AI Interviews: What People Want

Candidate experience in AI interviews, done right: clear disclosure, captions, no emotion analysis, real accommodations and Ontario's 45-day reply.

MSZ Hire Editorial Team
Talent acquisition and hiring science
7 min read

Updated

Candidate experience
A laptop showing the AI interviewer orb with live captions and a Speak or Type toggle, a phone in text mode, and a 'Request a human' chip.
On this page

Ask anyone who has applied for jobs recently about one-way video interviews and you'll hear a familiar story. A countdown timer. A webcam staring back. A question you get one shot at. No idea who, or what, will watch it. Then silence.

So it's fair to ask: is candidate experience in an AI interview doomed to be the same? We don't think so. Most of what candidates dislike comes from design choices, and design choices can be changed. Here's what applicants tell recruiters, hiring forums and anyone who'll listen they actually want, and how to deliver it.

#What makes candidate experience in an AI interview good or bad?

It comes down to respect and control. A bad experience feels like being processed: rigid, opaque and one-sided. A good one feels like a well-run structured interview that just happens to be available at 9 p.m. on a Sunday, which for a parent working shifts in Brampton might be the only time they've got.

Here's the contrast, side by side:

Candidates dislike Candidates want
Finding out mid-way that it's AI Being told up front, in the posting and before they start
Camera on, with no way to opt out A captioned voice interview, with no-video, typed-answer or human alternatives on request
Wondering if their expressions are being scored A plain statement of what is (and isn't) analysed
One take, no retries, hard cut-offs Time to think, and control over when they've finished
No way out A visible route to an accommodation or a person
Silence afterwards A clear timeline and an actual reply

#1. Tell them it's AI, early and plainly

Nobody likes being surprised by a robot. The fix is cheap: say so in the job posting, again in the invitation, and once more on the welcome screen.

For Ontario employers with 25 or more employees, the posting part isn't optional. Since 1 January 2026, publicly advertised job postings must disclose AI used to screen, assess or select applicants. A general statement is enough. Having a human make the final decision doesn't remove that duty, so don't lean on it. Our step-by-step guide to running your first AI interview includes a disclosure line you can adapt.

In MSZ Hire, the welcome screen tells candidates who invited them, that the interview is conducted by an AI interviewer and reviewed by the hiring team, roughly how long it takes, and that humans decide. Before they start, a consent checkbox asks them to confirm they understand it's conducted by AI and that the hiring team will review their answers.

#2. Make the voice interview easy, and accommodations easier

Some people think best out loud. Others freeze when a microphone is on, have a speech or hearing disability, or don't have a working camera.

MSZ Hire interviews are spoken and on camera. The interviewer asks each question aloud, live captions show the candidate's words as they speak, and a quick camera and microphone check runs before the first question. If the browser blocks the camera or mic, the candidate is told how to allow it. Anyone who can't take the interview that way can request an accommodation before they start: typed answers, an interview without video, or a human interview. The hiring team reviews each request, and typed answers use the same questions and the same scoring.

The camera and microphone are recorded so the hiring team can review the interview, and the notice says so before the candidate consents. Recordings are kept for 180 days and then deleted, and candidates can ask for earlier deletion.

"Same scoring" is a promise you should verify, not just print. Compare results for accommodated and non-accommodated candidates as they come in.

#3. Don't judge their face, voice or emotions

This is the big one. Much of the unease around one-way video comes from the suspicion that software is reading facial expressions, eye contact or "enthusiasm". Those signals are a poor basis for hiring decisions and a fast way to disadvantage people with disabilities, people from different cultures, and anyone who's simply nervous.

The clearest commitment is not to collect those signals at all. MSZ Hire's candidate notice says it plainly: "The AI scores only what you say. It never analyzes your face, expressions or voice." Candidates answer by voice (or in writing, with an approved accommodation), and the AI compares the content of their answers with the role's criteria. The interview is recorded on camera so people can review it, but the recording is never scored. Recruiters see quoted evidence for every rating, linked to the transcript.

#4. Offer a human alternative

Some candidates will want, or need, a person. Make that easy to find before the interview starts, not buried in an FAQ.

In MSZ Hire, the welcome screen asks: "Need an accommodation or prefer a person?" with a link to request a human alternative. Behind that link, you decide what the alternative is: a phone screen with a recruiter, the same structured questions asked live, or extra time.

There's a legal angle in Quebec too. When a decision about a person is based exclusively on automated processing, section 12.1 of Quebec's private-sector privacy law (as amended by Law 25) requires telling them, and on request explaining the information and principal factors used and giving them a chance to submit observations to someone who can review the decision. Keeping a human genuinely in the loop, and making that visible, is good practice everywhere. Our post on Quebec Law 25 and AI interviews goes deeper.

#5. Make accessibility the default, not a favour

In Ontario, the accessibility standards for employment require employers, when applicants are individually selected for an assessment or selection process, to tell them that accommodations are available on request for the materials or processes used. If a selected applicant asks, the employer must consult with them and provide or arrange a suitable accommodation.

An AI interview can make a lot of that easier by building it in:

  • Typed answers as an accommodation for candidates who are Deaf or hard of hearing or have a speech disability, and no-video interviews for anyone who can't use a camera.
  • Live captions throughout, so candidates can see their words as they speak.
  • Candidate-controlled pacing. In MSZ Hire, candidates press Done with my answer when they've finished, rather than being cut off mid-sentence.
  • A clear progress indicator: "Question 2 of 4" and a timer, so nobody is guessing how much is left.
  • A one-click route to an accommodation request before they start.

Built-in features don't replace the individual conversation the law requires when someone asks. They just mean fewer people have to ask.

#6. Reply, and say when you will

The single most common candidate complaint, about any interview format, is hearing nothing back.

In Ontario, the employer must tell applicants it interviewed whether a decision has been made about the position within 45 days of the last interview. MSZ Hire's confirmation screen tells Ontario candidates exactly that: the hiring team will review their answers, and they'll hear about the outcome within 45 days.

Telling them the date is half the job. Meeting it is the other half. Because scorecards are ready for review soon after the interview, with evidence linked to the transcript, recruiters can clear a queue in an afternoon rather than letting it age.

#A quick candidate-experience checklist

Before you launch, walk through the interview yourself as a candidate. Ask:

  • Did I know it was AI before I clicked the link?
  • Could I see live captions, and find how to request typed answers, no video or a person?
  • Was I told what is and isn't analysed, and how long the recording is kept?
  • Could I find a way to ask for an accommodation or a person?
  • Did I control when each answer was finished?
  • Did I know when I'd hear back?
  • Was there anywhere to say how the experience went? (MSZ Hire ends with a one-to-five-star rating.)

If any answer is "no", fix that before candidates find it for you.

#See it from the candidate's side

The fastest way to judge candidate experience in an AI interview is to sit in the candidate's chair. Take the twelve-minute candidate interview demo: nothing is sent to a recruiter (the demo recording stays in your browser tab), and you'll see the disclosure, the camera and microphone check, the accommodation request, the consent step and the 45-day message exactly as an applicant would.

Frequently asked questions

Why do candidates dislike one-way video interviews?

The common complaints are recording yourself to a blank screen with a countdown, not knowing who or what will watch it, worrying about being judged on appearance or expressions, and then hearing nothing back. Most of those are design choices, not inevitable features of AI interviews.

Do I have to tell candidates an AI is interviewing them?

In Ontario, employers with 25 or more employees must disclose AI used to screen, assess or select applicants in publicly advertised job postings. Beyond the law, telling candidates up front is simply better experience: surprise is what makes people feel tricked.

Should candidates be able to skip the AI and talk to a person?

Offer it. Some candidates need an accommodation, some have a poor connection, and some simply aren't comfortable. A visible human alternative costs little and removes a major source of anxiety. Under Ontario's accessibility rules, you also have to tell selected applicants that accommodations are available on request.

Can candidates type their answers instead of speaking?

As an approved accommodation, yes. MSZ Hire interviews are spoken and on camera, with live captions. A candidate who can't answer by voice, for example because of a speech or hearing disability, can request typed answers before starting; others can ask for an interview without video, or a human interview. Typed answers use the same questions and the same scoring, and you should check your results to confirm accommodated candidates aren't penalised.

How quickly should candidates hear back after an AI interview?

Fast enough that they don't wonder. In Ontario, employers must tell interviewed applicants whether a decision has been made within 45 days of the last interview. Faster is kinder, and easier when scorecards are ready for review the same day.

Sources

  1. 1.Ontario: Your guide to the Employment Standards Act, requirements related to publicly advertised job postings (opens in a new tab)
  2. 2.Accessible Campus (Council of Ontario Universities): Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation, section 23, recruitment, assessment or selection process (opens in a new tab)
  3. 3.Torys LLP: Automated decision-making under Quebec's Law 25 (opens in a new tab)
  • #candidate experience
  • #AI interviews
  • #one-way video interviews
  • #accessibility
  • #AODA
Share

Written by

MSZ Hire Editorial Team

Talent acquisition and hiring science, MSZ Systems

The MSZ Hire team builds structured AI interviews for employers across the US and Canada. We write about what we learn from talent leaders, candidates and regulators.

MSZ Hire

AI interviews you can defend.

Structured interviews, evidence-backed scoring and built-in compliance for the US and Canada. See it on one of your own roles.

All articles
An automated interview pipeline hands off to a human reviewer who makes the decision, with an EN / FR language chip, a bilingual notice and a candidate's request for the reasons behind a decision.
Hiring compliance

Quebec Law 25 AI Hiring: When Section 12.1 Applies

Quebec Law 25 AI hiring guide: what an exclusively automated decision is, why a real human decision matters, plus a bilingual candidate notice.

8 min read
A four-step workflow connected left to right: build the role, invite candidates, run the AI interview, and a human makes the decision.
Product guides

How to Use an AI Interview Platform: Your First Interview

How to use an AI interview platform, step by step: build a role, write Ontario's AI disclosure line, invite candidates and review evidence-based scores.

9 min read
The MSZ Hire AI orb at the centre with the blog's six categories orbiting it: AI and the workforce, hiring compliance, product guides, fair and validated AI, candidate experience and high-volume hiring.
Product guides

Welcome to the MSZ Hire blog

Why we started the MSZ Hire blog, what we'll cover on AI interviews, fair hiring and compliance, and how to get the most out of each guide.

1 min read